Beautiful Darkness Book Discussion:Week 4

Posted 23 November, 2010 by Danny in / 9 Comments

Welcome to the Beautiful Darkness Book Discussion!! Over the next nine weeks we will be discussing Beautiful Darkness a few chapters at a time with posts and discussion questions by a variety of guest posters. Posts and discussion questions will go up on Tuesdays and recaps of the discussion question answers will go up on Sundays. For the complete schedule of chapters and dates click here.

Also, as we are the Bookworms and are physically incapable of not hosting a give-away for any major event on this blog, there’s a give-away going on in conjunction with the discussion! WOOT!! Find out all about that here as well.

And now a warning….while we will keep each week’s post spoiler free for those who have only read up to and including the chapters being discussed that week, if you haven’t read the book at all you will find spoilers about the sections of the book being discussed. SO…if you haven’t read the book at all…STOP. GET THE BOOK. READ IT. RETURN. Easy, peasy, extra cheesy, right, Cutie? And in conjunction with that, we do ask that all of you participating in the discussion please keep your responses spoiler free. We know this can be hard but please have a heart for those who are enjoying the read-along aspect of the discussion and do your best. We in turn will do our best to monitor the comments.

And finally….on with this week’s discussion written by Suzie from I Adore Books & Film!!!!

This week’s chapters:

6.12 Caster Boy

Still reeling from Lena’s behavior at the lake, Ethan is hurt and confused. As Link and Ethan head back in Lena’s car, Link is amused at driving Lena’s fastback, while Ethan brews over the guy that Lena left with. In Ethan’s heart, something is amiss but he’s just not sure what it is, and he refuses to come to grips that Lena is changing.

The two stop off at the Dar-ee Keen and again, Ethan’s mind is spinning with questions about Lena. Could she really choose to be Light or Dark? Was it that easy? Unnecessary banter from the kids of Jackson High seems to lighten the mood, but like a cheesy western…

“He was standing in the doorway in a faded black T-shirt,
jeans, and scuffed black army boots.”

Simultaneously, Ethan’s unusual scar on his stomach starts to ache and throb. Though Link questions if this young man is one of Lena’s relatives, Ethan senses otherwise. Behind the young man, strolls in Ridley -skin tight, lacy black tank, black skirt and all.

It is then that Ethan can finally put a name to the face, John Breed, as the mysterious young man introduces himself. There is obvious tension between the two, as Ethan retaliates by making sure to relay to John that he is Lena’s boyfriend.

Strangely the antics continue with Ridley now commenting on how Lena and she have worked things out. Baffled, Ethan listens but is able to put 2 and 2 together. The bike, it’s his. This is who Lena has been running to.

After returning Lena’s car to Ravenwood, Ethan “gets emo” by rummaging through a shoe box of memories. I think this is important because Ethan must remind himself of the Lena that he had come to love, and not the Lena that has been shutting him out. We end the chapter with good-ole Amma placing a red string around Ethan’s wrist-it is a tie to the Otherworld.

6.14 Bookworm

It is the first day of summer, and god bless Ethan. He is spending it with Marian in the library working. BUT! As the previous chapter was important for the formal introduction of John, this chapter we meet a young woman; blonde, British and lanky. Olvia Durand, Liv to her friends, Marian’s new summer intern.

“She was nothing like Lena, but nothing like the girls in Gatlin either.”

It is clear from the beginning, that Liv knows all about Ethan, much to his surprise, but Ethan is still too upset over Lena to really engage back. Desperate to take his mind off her, he remembers why he took the job to begin with: to find more information. But he takes his frustrations out on Marian, knowing that as a Keeper, there is nothing she can do to stop the actions that are set forth. After all, nobody was able to save Ethan’s mom and this bitter memory plagues both Marian and Ethan.

Alone, Ethan holds the book “Darkness and Light: The Origins of Magic”, and suddenly things become chaotic, as Ethan bends down to pick up a gum wrapper that his mother used as a bookmark. The room blurs and he falls dizzily to the ground.

Ethan is having a vision: We see Abraham return to Ravenwood, called by the book. The book seems to be alive, flipping its pages, offering what it knew Abraham wanted. But what would it ask for in exchange? Before him, read the words to a Caste.

Then appears Jonah, desperate to flee and save his brother. But he sees what Abraham is reading. “The Daemonis Pactum-The Deamon’s Trade”.

The two begin to argue and Abraham pushes Jonah back. Determined to save Ravenwood, Abraham calls out the chant. Jonah screams for him to stop, but it is too late. Unfortunately, from Jonah’s pocket rolls a glowing sphere. Picking it up, Abraham questions why Jonah would have an Archlight; a vessel capable of imprisonment. Jonah only wanted to protect Abraham from himself, but in anger, Abraham lunges forward, sinking his teeth into his brother’s shoulder. Abraham has drunken blood and murdered his brother. At the end of the vision, Abraham turns and mutters “Ethan.”

Marian finds Ethan on the floor. As he relays the events that flashed before him, Marian is both concerned and confused. How all this relates to Ethan, is still a mystery to her, but she begs Ethan to speak of this to no one, not even Amma. In the end, Ethan realizes that he is on his own.

6.12 The Girl In My Dreams

It’s back to business, as Ethan is asked to deliver brown packages which hold library selections for people-who-are-too-lazy-for-the-library. Liv is asked to go with Ethan. After finishing their deliveries, Ethan suspects Marian really only wanted him to work at the library so that he could double as a tour guide for Liv.

Both Liv and Ethan decide to stop and eat at Dar-ee Keen, and low and behold, Liv can throw down (the girl can eat).

The two seem to get along and take this opportunity to get to know each other, with Ethan giving Liv some much needed lessons in “how to speak American”. Regardless, it is cute and as a reader you have to wonder if this simple exchange of carefree dialogue-two kids hanging out-will ever be meant for Ethan and Lena. Speaking of…

As the two head out the door, a Fastback makes a u-turn, and skids out of the area.

That night, Ethan lays in bed thinking about all the changes that had taken place. Mentally, he knows he still loves Lena. But Lena is keeping secrets and worst, keeping herself from Ethan. Then the visions… it all means something but Ethan struggles to piece it together.

Looking to grab some fresh air, Ethan sticks his head out his window. Below, at the edge of the porch Boo Radley the dog sits loyally next to Lucille Ball the cat. Ethan falls asleep to the two pets and their quiet conversation.

6.15 Southern Crusty

And we’re off to the fair! Ethan does a nice job of recapping past events; as it is all about “pies and pageants”, as we get an understanding of what it’s like to live in Gatlin.

As Amma gets herself situated for the County Fair Pie contest, Ethan stumbles off to find Link. Guess who else he finds? Liv! After introductions are made, and Link pulls his bottom jaw off the ground, mesmerized by Liv’s beauty, we can’t help but sense something is brewing. (Oh don’t act like you didn’t see this one coming).

“Ethan, I’ve been looking for you.” Lena walked toward me, and she sounded like herself, her old self-the Lena I remembered from a few months ago.

But Ethan uses this opportunity to remind Lena where she left him last, alone at the lake. Defensive, she argues back, as if it were no big deal. But the tear that falls from her eye, tells otherwise. She kelts to him that she loves him and then repeats it out loud.

Again, Ethan questions Lena, asking her to confide in him, tell him who John Breed is; explain to him what the hell is going on.

But Lena continues to dodge his questions, and only insists that John is just a friend. Ethan fires back about Ridley and reminds Lena of what her cousin did to him and his family. In the heat of their argument, they kiss each other, eager to allow their passion for one another to drown out the reality that surrounds them. But the kiss becomes unbearable, as fire begins to consume Ethan.

Temporarily, the kiss quelled their altercation but here comes Liv, obliviously to the turmoil. This sends Lena in a jealous rage, and she confesses to Ethan that she always knew this would happen. Like a tornado, she leaves with a wake of turbulence as things fall, break and burst behind her.

Frustrated, Link, Ethan and Liv head to the tent for the pie contest.

Discussion Question:

A lot seems to be happening in these last chapters, as we formally meet John Breed (and get confirmation that he indeed knows Lena) and Liv Durand, Marian’s summer intern. Then there is the vision. What is made clear is that Abraham in his actions has certainly cursed the family, but eerily, seems to be calling out to Ethan at the end of the vision. For what purpose, is still unknown. But as if Ethan doesn’t have enough on his plate, he collides violently with Lena at the fair. Meeting Liv, Lena leaves like scorned lover.

My question to you all:

Considering that Ridley
tried to have Ethan’s father
jump that fateful night,
do you think Ethan feels
any sort of betrayal from Lena
for allowing Ridley
back into her life?

Thank you, so much, Suzie, for a great review of this week’s chapters and a great question! Leave your answer in a comment below and remember that each answer to this week’s discussion question is an entry into the Beautiful Darkness Book Discussion contest!

Obsessive Reader by Night – Scientist at Day!
You can also find me on goodreads. I’d love to get to know you so, don’t be shy and say Hello!

Tags: , , ,

Divider

9 Responses to “Beautiful Darkness Book Discussion:Week 4”

  1. I'm sure Ethan does feel betrayed. Not only because Ridley tried to make his father commit suicide but because she had repeatedly tricked Ethan. I think Ethan is probably hurt that Lena would shut him out and not someone who was a threat to her whole family. Even the fact that Ridley had broken Link's heart after tricking him into falling for her would be enough for Ethan to be upset by Lena's reforged bond with Ridley.

  2. I do not think that Ethan feels so much betrayed as he does shocked. He probably doesn't understand why she would do such a thing, it is most likely unfathomable. I think feels more betrayed by the fact that she is hanging out with John Breed than by that she is hanging out with Ridley. Ethan knows of Lena's soft spot for her. He knows that she wasn't always Dark and she used to be Lena's best friend.

  3. This is absolutely tough for Ethan. In fact Ridley messed with everyone and of course Ethan feels betrayed and shocked.
    But, I think it's not just that, it's also his worst fear – that Lena will turn Darker and Darker the more she hangs out with Ridley and of course John. I think they are a bad influence and I believe Ethan thinks the same, so I'd say his fears for Lena are stronger than feeling betrayed.

    Great post Sweetie!!
    My recent post Pleasy Cheesy !

  4. Caroline, you bring up an important point that Ethan would feel Lena's betrayal of Link as well. And choosing to trust Ridley over him would rankle as well. Excellent points!

  5. While I still think Ethan feels betrayed by Lena's renewed relationship with Ridley, it's clear he's able to justify it based on their family connection. You may not like your family but you're bound to them in complex ways that transcend their actions oftentimes. But I agree with you 100% about John Breed. Intentional or not, this is a betrayal that must cut deep.

  6. Greta is Erikasbuddy

    I soo bet he does!! Why wouldn't he!! SHe's hanging out with the enemy!! But that's my opinion 🙂 I know I would feel hurt if the same thing happened to me.

    P.S. I lovers your pic of John Breed!!

  7. What a fantastic question!
    I think there is more shock than feeling of betrayal at this point. But I don't think he'd feel so betrayed by Lena's reconnection with Ridley if she wasn't pushing him out at the same time and I completely agree that it's a lot of his worst fears being realized. Lena's surrounding herself with darkness rather than trying to pull herself closer to the light.
    The fact that he'd feel even more betrayed by the presence of John Breed in her life is an excellent point as well. It's not as though she and Ethan have officially ended anything and suddenly he finds out there is another guy in the picture. All the while she's pushing him away and seems to have been running toward this guy. Definitely a lot for Ethan to digest.

Leave a Reply to Britta Cancel reply

CommentLuv badge